Welcome back! I’m flying to Las Vegas this morning for CES. Keep reading The Technology 202 for the latest tech policy developments at the show. Also follow along with my colleagues Heather Kelly and Geoffrey Fowler, who are already discovering new innovations and getting (temporary) tattoos of The Post’s editor Marty Baron.
Ctrl + N
Democratic presidential hopeful Massachusetts Senator Elizabeth Warren (L) and former Vice President Joe Biden participate of the sixth Democratic primary debate in December. (Photo by FREDERIC J. BROWN/AFP via Getty Images)
Over the last decade, lawmakers and regulators slowly woke up to the consequences of the tech industry’s unchecked rise in power. In the 2020s, they’ll try to take back control.
The decade will kick off with a bang: Tech companies will feel the heat this year from a presidential election, increased antitrust scrutiny in Washington and a new privacy law that’s just coming into effect in California. Expect Congress to be focused on tech’s role in the campaigns and fighting off disinformation, while states also make greater investments in regulating the industry.
Here are (some) of the top issues we’ll be tracking at The Technology 202 in 2020:
1. Tech companies will grapple with their responsibility to separate fact from fiction online — especially during a closely watched presidential election cycle.
Their first test of 2020 came before many had even recovered from their New Years’ celebrations. A deceptively edited video of former vice president Joe Biden that widely circulated on Twitter last week could be a harbinger of disinformation in the election.
Twitter confirmed Friday that it would not remove the 19-second clip, which was edited to make the Democratic presidential candidate appear racist. The video’s spread was bolstered by several reporters and people with large Twitter followings, who shared it with little context.
As my colleague Greg Sargent wrote: “If you thought the 2016 election was awash in disinformation and lies, get ready: The 2020 election is going to make that affair look like a knitting session.”
Biden is warning that any Democratic nominee would be vulnerable to disinformation in the aftermath of the video’s spread, according to The New York Times. That could put even more pressure on Silicon Valley companies to invest in rooting out falsehoods on their platform and set the stage for battles between candidates and companies in the coming years.
2. Disinformation tactics will evolve as Silicon Valley invests heavily to avoid a repeat of the 2016 election.
The cast of actors who could potentially target the 2020 races is much broader – and their arsenal of weapons is constantly evolving.
Russia is no longer the only threat. Iran and China have shown that they are also investing in influence operations on social media. Domestic actors also played a significant role in spreading disinformation in the 2018 midterms.
The edited Biden video, and a doctored video of House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) that went viral last year, show how powerful video editing can be in creating a false political narrative. And researchers warn that deepfakes – which allow people to use artificial intelligence to make it appear someone is saying or doing something that never happened – are developing swiftly and creating new concerns.
Expect these evolutions to be a key focus of Washington lawmakers in the coming weeks. The House Energy and Commerce Committee will kick things off Wednesday with a hearing on “manipulation and deception in the digital age.”
3. California’s new privacy law took effect on Jan. 1, and other states will consider adopting their own data-collection restrictions in the absence of federal action.
It’s official. California residents have new controls over their privacy. But tech companies still have some time before enforcement of the law begins in six months, so expect them to spend the first half of the year adjusting to the new regulation.
In the absence of federal action in Washington last year, other states are considering their own privacy legislation. The tech industry is closely watching states like New York and Washington, which could adopt their own privacy legislation in the coming months.
This flurry of activity at the state level is prompting the industry’s lobbying groups to invest more in states, Axios’s Kim Hart and Margaret Harding McGill write. States are also expected to take a greater role on issues such as autonomous vehicles and facial recognition.
4. Tech giants’ power and size will be under the microscope as antitrust investigations heat up at the federal and state level.
Antitrust will continue to dominate the tech policy debate, especially as the House subcommittee leading an antitrust investigation into Big Tech plans to release a report on its findings in the first half of 2020.
The action on the Hill comes as the Federal Trade Commission and Justice Department have their own ongoing probes of the tech giants, and states attorneys general are also launching investigations of companies including Facebook and Google.
Any developments in these investigations could become a key topic on the campaign trail. Many Democratic candidates have been weighing in on their positions on breaking up Big Tech as they try to differentiate their economic platforms.
5. The industry’s treatment of contract workers will face a reckoning — starting with a law targeting gig-economy workers known as AB5 in California.
Companies like Uber, Lyft and Postmates built entirely new business models by relying heavily on contract workers to power their driving and delivery workforces. But a new law in California that aims to reclassify these gig workers as full-time employees could pose an existential threat to that way of doing business.
AB5 took effect last week, and the companies are stepping up their efforts to ensure that they don’t have to reclassify their drivers. My colleague Faiz Siddiqui this morning reports that Uber has launched an internal initiative known as “Project Luigi” to fight the law. The initiative aimed to revamp aspects of the app to make it more friendly to California drivers, including adding the ability to see estimated trip fares up front and then reject a trip without penalty.
The Wall Street Journal reported last week that Uber and Postmates sued California to challenge the legislation on the grounds that it “violates constitutional guarantees of equal protection and due process because of how it targets some workers and companies.” They’re also pushing a ballot initiative to counter the law in California in 2020.
2020 Election: BITS, NIBBLES AND BYTES
Demonstrators chant anti-U.S. slogans as they protest the killing of Iranian commander Qasem Soleimani. (Lefteris Pitarakis/AP)
BITS: Analysts and former U.S. officials warn that Iran could retaliate against a U.S. airstrike that killed one of its top generals with a variety of cyberattacks, my colleagues Tony Romm, Isaac Stanley-Becker and Craig Timberg report. The potential attacks could hit a number of critical sectors, including the energy industry and American banking systems, experts warn.
“Anywhere where they can cause serious, almost psychological effects, noticeable disruption,” is a target, John Hultquist, director of intelligence analysis for the cybersecurity company FireEye, told my colleagues. “The purpose is to prove to the public that they can reach out and touch Americans.”
Since the U.S. killing of Iranian commander Qasem Soleimani, experts tracking disinformation efforts have noticed suspicious activity from accounts pushing pro-Iran messaging on social media and messaging apps, presenting another possible proxy for cyberwar. Researchers found that social media accounts formerly used for commercial reasons, for instance, had quickly been repurposed for coordinated pro-Iran messaging. Researchers witnessed similar coordinated messaging on the messenger app Telegram.
Lawmakers are also concerned. “We know that Iranian cyberoperations are currently scoping and preparing to attack our networks — in all sectors of society — to see where they can hit us,” said Sen. Mark R. Warner (Va.), the top Democrat on the Senate Intelligence Committee. The Department of Homeland Security and the White House did not respond to requests for comment.
NIBBLES: Users have flooded TikTok with political content in recent weeks, despite the Chinese-owned app’s effort to avoid the limelight of the 2020 social media race, Georgia Wells and Emily Glazer at the Wall Street Journal report. Videos tagged with #Trump2020 were viewed more than 200 million times in the last three weeks of 2019, they found.
TikTok banned political ads last year, but advisers from both parties have expressed interest in partnering with influencers on the app to reach young voters. The Trump campaign does not maintain an official page, but it has reached out to influential accounts on the platform, a person familiar with the matter told the Journal.
U.S. agencies are ramping up warnings that the Chinese-owned app could pose a national security threat. The Democratic National Committee issued a notice last month warning campaigns that the app could potentially be sending data back to the Chinese government and advising campaigns not to use it. The Republican National Committee did not respond to a request for comment from the Journal.
(Nicholas Kamm/AFP/Getty Images)
The Trump administration today is implementing greater restrictions on U.S. companies seeking to export some location technologies for drones, sensors and satellites, Alexandra Alper at Reuters reports. The rule aims to keep sensitive U.S. developments in artificial intelligence out of the hands of rival states such as China.
“They want to keep American companies from helping the Chinese make better AI products that can help their military,” James Lewis, a technology expert with the Washington-based Center for Strategic and International Studies, told Reuters. The rule will probably be welcomed by industry leaders who feared a much wider crackdown on artificial intelligence products, Lewis noted.
The rule, which stems from a 2018 mandate tasking the Commerce Department with regulating the export of sensitive technologies, follows growing bipartisan frustration with the administration’s slow rollout of export controls. The Commerce Department has introduced similar controls for advanced telecommunications equipment.
2020 Election: PRIVATE CLOUD
The CES logo in the lobby of the Las Vegas Convention Center on Sunday. (Steve Marcus/Reuters)
— CES kicks off Tuesday, and attendees can expect a keynote address by Ivanka Trump and attempts to rebrand facial identification technology as consumer friendly, my colleague Heather reports. This is also the first year the 50-year-old event will allow sex toys onto its vendor show floor. Not present this year will be previous CES winners Ezviz and iFlytek. Ezviz’s parent company Hikvision and iFlytek are blacklisted by the U.S. Commerce Department over their alleged use in human rights violations by the Chinese government. which are blacklisted by the U.S. Commerce Department over their alleged use in human rights violations by the Chinese government.
Correction: This item has been updated to reflect that Ezviz’s parent company Hikvision, not Ezviz, is blacklisted by the Commerce Department.
— More news from the private sector:
2020 Election: PUBLIC CLOUD
— News from the public sector:
2020 Election: #TRENDING
— Tech news generating buzz around the Web:
2020 Election: CHECK-INS
— Coming up:
- CES takes place Tuesday through Friday in Las Vegas.
- The Subcommittee on Consumer Protection and Commerce of the House Energy Committee will hold a hearing, “Americans at Risk: Manipulation and Deception in the Digital Age,” on Wednesday at 10: 30 a.m.
- Mobile World Congress takes place Feb. 24-27 in Barcelona.